10 Signs You’re Dating the Wrong Person – From a Man’s Perspective

Are you dating the wrong person? Are you currently dating? Are you wondering if the red flags are BIG enough reasons to break up? Are your friends and family concerned about the relationship? If you answered yes to any of these questions, then this post is for you. If you feel in your heart that something is just not right about your relationship – don’t ignore these feelings. This could be the Holy Spirit leading you to break up. Today Sam Eaton will share 10 signs that you may be dating the wrong person.

Share your thoughts and dating experiences in the comment section below! xoxo Joy

She was easily the most hilarious person I have ever met. Our alarmingly sudden spark ignited as we collided at a drinking fountain outside a roaring great wedding reception. Her kind, brown eyes whispered, “let’s have an adventure” and her smile was like a crazy NASA invention that magnetically forced a grin across my boyish face.

Before I knew it our lives were entangled as we spent almost every day together checking out hipster dive bars with the best french fries in town and sipping homemade root beer while cheering on pig races.

It all happened so fast that I didn’t stop to think about a future; she made me feel alive in the present and that’s all I really cared about. The truth is, all the signs were there that she wasn’t what I was truly looking for, but that didn’t seem to stop me. (Check out Joy’s Post on How to Find God’s Will In Who to Date.)

Over the last five years, my perspective on dating has been completely turned upside down. I started to ask a really tough question, “Does God care who I date?” Survey Says: DUH! Of course God cares! God is the perfect father and what good father wouldn’t have a (strong) opinion about who his child is dating?

About two months after becoming official, I had a sudden moment of confusion and clarity. This girl was totally wrong for me and we wanted entirely different things in life. Yet, no part of me wanted to let her go. She had become the center of my world and my big head had fallen for her over my clumsy heels.

The fallout was a heartbreak that I wasn’t ready for and that could have been prevented. All these years later, I can see so many warning signs that I completely ignored. I just wish someone had been around to point them out to me. So, in hopes of being that friend for you, here are:

10 Signs You’re Dating the Wrong Person

1.) The people who know you the best aren’t very impressed.

Trust the Godly people who have known you the longest – your family, your friends, your mentors (especially those who are older than you). They have way more life experience to see things you cannot. Often God speaks to us through these people: listen.

2.) People say you’ve changed a lot since you started dating them.

Of course you will change when you enter a relationship, but the core of your identity should
remain the same, regardless of who you’re dating.

3.) You’ve stopped making time for the people who matter.

Most of us have experienced this story: as soon as a friend gets in a relationship you barely
ever hear from them again or, even worse, seeing them without their “other half” is as rare as
finding a unicorn. The right person should be encouraging you to strengthen, not neglect, the most important relationships in your life.

4.) He/she keeps pushing physical boundaries and/or is all about the public displays of affection (PDA).

If you have talked boundaries and you keep going farther, maybe it’s time to evaluate what that’s really about and what that might mean for your relationship in other areas. A little hand holding never hurt anyone, but constant touching in public is often a sign of insecurity.

Haven’t set physical boundaries or want to learn more? (Check out the benefits of boundaries in dating.)

5.) They are distracting your relationship with God.

The right relationship should encourage your personal relationship with God, not distract from it. This should always be our focus: “Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength. The second is this: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself. There is no commandment greater than these.” Mark 12:30-31 (NIV).

6.) You don’t see yourself marrying them or parenting with them.

This one should be obvious, but it wasn’t for me. I wanted to believe that the big issues in our relationship were a problem for future Sam to worry about. Yet, I was creating a deep love for someone who didn’t want a family when that’s all I’ve ever wanted. Obviously you don’t have to know in the first weeks, but make sure your non-negotiables line up from the start.

7.) He/She doesn’t take the time to get to know your parents, your siblings and your best friends.

If you are truly going to spend your life with this person, he/she is going to be spending a lot of time with your people. If he/she isn’t making an effort now, it’s pretty unlikely that this will change in the future. Loving these people is an essential part of loving you.

8.) They aren’t really going anywhere in their own future.

You shouldn’t be their entire 10 year plan. Are they making good decisions regardless of yours or are they treading water just to be with you? They should be working towards a better tomorrow whether you are a part of that or not.

9.) Your big life dreams aren’t as bright as they were before you started dating them.

The truth is most people don’t chase their biggest dreams, they abandon them and settle for an average life. Whoever you are with for the long haul should be making your dreams bigger, not smaller and closer, not farther away.

10.) You find yourself making excuses to yourself (and others) about their actions.

Whatever the warning sign, you always have an answer ready to let them off the hook instead of confronting the real issues. You shouldn’t have to constantly defend the right person. I am not saying that you should immediately ditch your “beau” if you feel convicted by one of these signs; we know that no one is perfect. Yet, when present, they scream something about your partner’s heart that I, 27 year old Sam, begs you not to ignore.

The truth is, even now, I still miss that crazy girl sometimes. I could have sat around drinking in her hilarious punch lines and free-spirit for many years. Yet, I know that what we had was never God’s design for a relationship and certainly not for a marriage.

Be smart about who you are investing your future in and with whom you are spending your time. Check in with people who love you throughout this journey to talk about what they see and how you feel. Put some safeguards in place to protect your heart and to make sure your dating relationship is honoring God. And, when you find that person, the human who fits in your life, brings you closer to God, and makes you excited about your future together, you’ll finally start to understand just how good a Christ-centered relationship can be. And that, my friends, more than anything, is worth the wait.

Do you agree with these warning signs? What would you add to this list? Join the conversation in the comment section below!

Meet Sam: Sam Eaton writes at RecklesslyAlive.com and is a monthly contributor to JP Ministries. Sam’s heart for Jesus is contagious. He’s a music teacher by day, and a youth minister and worship musician by night. You can friend him on twitter @aliverecklessly.

Are you dating the wrong person?

Hello New Friend – Join Our Email List!

* indicates required

14 Comments on 10 Signs You’re Dating the Wrong Person – From a Man’s Perspective

  1. Nastashya
    July 24, 2016 at 5:54 pm (5 years ago)

    I can identify with 5 of 10 signs. I’m currently praying about my relationship and if I’m with the man God intended for me to be with. Thank you for your post.

    • joypedrow
      July 25, 2016 at 4:57 pm (5 years ago)

      Thanks for the comment. I will pray right now for God to reveal to you if you should continue dating him or break up with him. Remember, you can’t mess up God’s plan for your life.

      • Nastashya
        July 25, 2016 at 5:08 pm (5 years ago)

        Thank you very much. I really appreciate that. I will continue to pray for revelation. I don’t want to ruin my relationship with God because of my relationship with boyfriend. I know God has a plan for me and I just need a sign to know how to move forward with this.


        • Eliana
          April 25, 2017 at 12:11 pm (5 years ago)

          I’m in the same position. I’m save and my boyfriend isn’t what should I do?

          • Nastashya
            April 25, 2017 at 3:14 pm (5 years ago)

            Being unequally yoked causes a problem most time. Especially if your partner doesn’t have any intention of becoming a Christian.

            You will be going into two different directions, and that will complicate things. You can’t have both worlds. If the both of you are on the same path, then you will both be able to help each other along the journey of being pure and holy Christians.

            Because when you’re courting someone, things can get challenging.

            All the best

          • joypedrow
            April 28, 2017 at 10:30 am (5 years ago)

            Hi Eliana, I echo everything Nastashya said. I would break up with him. Dating a non-believer won’t bring you closer to Jesus. It will most likely bring you away from Jesus. I know this isn’t an easy step, and it requires lots of trust in God, but I believe God is bigger than our brains. God sees the whole picture. He knows your whole life story. Trust in him, and cry out to him during the pain. God will comfort you.
            Love, Joy

        • Nastashya
          April 25, 2017 at 3:09 pm (5 years ago)

          Well, we broke up and I am a very happy woman. God knows best!

          • joypedrow
            April 26, 2017 at 5:29 pm (5 years ago)

            I’m so proud of you for breaking up. I’m sure that was very hard, even if you are happy now. God does know what best. Thank you for bringing your wisdom to this post and comment thread! Love, Joy

            • Nastashya
              April 26, 2017 at 5:48 pm (5 years ago)

              And thank you so much Joy! You have a wonderful ministry helping young women like myself.

              Nuff Love & Blessings

            • Nastashya
              April 26, 2017 at 5:49 pm (5 years ago)

              And thank you so much Joy!

              Nuff Love & Blessings

  2. Michelle
    August 28, 2016 at 4:45 am (5 years ago)

    I think everything is true. Thank you!

    • Sam Eaton
      June 29, 2017 at 3:11 pm (5 years ago)

      Thank you so much Michelle!

  3. Dawn Dean
    June 21, 2017 at 9:25 am (5 years ago)

    Great column and good advice. My one piece of advice is echoed in all 10 “signs” indicated here: Shared VALUES matter, not shared INTERESTS. If you are a Christian do not disregard the Biblical admonishment to not be “unequally yoked.” You will be spared much heartache if you put Jesus No. 1 in screening dating partners. That doesn’t mean you’ll be on the same level of your faith journey but you’re on the same path. I’m happily married to a godly man because both of us put “shared Christian faith” at the top of our list. That has made more difference than anything the culture tells you should matter.

    • Sam Eaton
      June 29, 2017 at 3:13 pm (5 years ago)

      Such truth Dawn! I love how you made special mention of not being on the “same level” of faith journey. I think that’s so important that we don’t discredit someone or judge them based on where they’re at, but notice if they are open to and actively pursuing a deeper relationship with Jesus. Thank you so much for sharing your insight into this conversation!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comment *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.